My Ex-Girlfriend Had No Idea That I Fucked Her

Published early on our Previews page on Monday, June 3, 2024.

Official publication date for the main page of our site: Wednesday, June 12, 2024.

This illustrated story was submitted anonymously.

"Yo Johnny!" The text read. "Have you had any kinky fun lately?"

"I have a new play partner who's really into the stuff I like to do," I replied, "so yeah, it's been good. How about you?"

"Tami's been letting me do all kinds of kinky stuff to her the last couple of months," he told me.

Tami was my ex-girlfriend. Johnny started seeing her after I suggested that he might have better luck than me in getting her to be more sexually adventurous. Evidently, he did have better luck. I was happy for him, and for her, too.

"What do you mean by kinky stuff, and how did you get her interested in it?" I asked.

"You're the one who got her interested," he answered.

"I did?" I asked incredulously.

"Yeah," he texted back. "All that stuff about wanting to tie her up for sex made her think about what she might be missing, so when I asked if I could to that to her, she went for it."

"That's great!" I exclaimed. "How'd it go?"

"Way better than I expected," he told me, "and now she can't get enough of it. I even started surprising her with other guys, because as you know, I'm into that stuff, and now she's hooked on that, too."

"I'm really surprised," I replied. "I mean, she seemed so vanilla to me."

"She was vanilla," he confirmed. "She told me that she had never done anything kinky before. You know, being a good Catholic girl, and all. But she's sure into it now!"

"Well, my loss is your gain," I replied. "But it's all good. I'm happy for you."

"Are you sure?" He asked.

"Definitely," I assured him.

"Good to know," he texted back. "So ... question for you?"

"Shoot!" I replied.

"I know that it's short notice," he told me, "but I'm wondering if you and your play partner would like to come over to my place tonight to surprise Tami while she's blindfolded, gagged, and tied up like this pic?"

"That's not Tami," I texted back. "It's a good likeness, though."

"I couldn't send one of her," he explained. "She wouldn't want me to do that. It's a screen capture of a video I bought online just to show you what I planned for tonight."

"Hang tight," I told him. "Let me see if Debbie's into it."

"Your play partner?" He asked.

"Yep," I answered. "Hang tight."

"I'll get into the details later," I texted Debbie with the pic attachment that my friend sent, "but would you be interested in helping me to surprise my ex Tami? As you know, this isn't her ... just a pic that Robert sent me to show us how he's going to have Tami ready for her surprise. I won't go without you, and she won't know that we surprised her ... a kink that Robert gets off on ... and her, too apparently."

A few moments later Debbie sent me a five word text with a fire emoji that read, "Naughty, naughty. I'm all in!"

I thought that she might react like that, so I was pleased, and so was Robert when I copied, and pasted my text, and Debbie's to him.

"Great!" He exclaimed. "See you at 8pm."

"See you then," I replied.

Debbie got back from her errands about forty-five minutes after our texts, and I filled her in on all of the details. She already knew about Tami, and why we broke up. Ironically, Debbie had previously teased me from time to time with the idea of having her seduce Tami into getting tied up so that the two of us could sexually dominate her.

With me, Debbie is wonderfully submissive, but with women she's decidedly dominant. One of her kinks is to seduce straight women into bondage sex so that she can show them how satisfying it is to have a woman get them off while they're tied and helpless to do anything about it. Debbie's take on it is that it gives straight women an excuse to be with another woman; you know, being forced to do it instead of doing it on their own.

When we got to Robert's place as scheduled, I texted him, and he came to the front door to let us inside. Debbie easily convinced him to let Tami think that she was alone with her just to see where she might be able to go with it.

"It's amazing how may straight women love having another woman get them off, especially when they're tied and helpless to do anything about it. But don't worry," Debbie teased both of us, "the two of you can stay, and watch. Just be quiet, and I'll have her think that she's on her own with me. If it goes well, and it usually does, just sit back, enjoy the show, and follow my lead."

After Robert happily told Debbie to go for it, he quietly escorted us into his bedroom. Nobody said a word.

Debbie stretched both of her arms apart so that she could glide her fingers along both of Tami's sexy wrinkled soles at the same time. Tami scrunched her toes, and kind of gasped through the ball gag when Debbie tickled her soles a little harder.

"Ticklish are we?" She playfully asked. "I love ticklish feet."

Tami gasped at the sound of hearing a woman's voice instead of Robert's, and she gasped again when Debbie started to suck the big toe of Tami's right foot.

"If you're wondering," Debbie interrupted her toe sucking, "I sent Robert away for a while so that we can get acquainted better, and oh am I going to have fun with you."

Tami let out a moan of approval. She was clearly intrigued about having a woman play with her. Debbie traced Tami's naked and bound body with her fingers, and her warm, wet tongue, starting at each, and every one of her toes, and all the way up to her neck.

Giving Tami a real opportunity to object, but also to give her comfort, Debbie gently removed the ball gag from Tami's mouth, and told her, "I don't want your jaw to get too sore."

"Thank you," Tami replied. "It was starting to get a little sore."

"I thought that it might," Debbie told her before gently caressing the back of her neck, and giving her a passionate kiss.

To Robert's surprise, and mine, Tami passionately returned Debbie's kiss. While the kissing continued, Debbie reached down to finger Tami's pussy and clit, and Tami let out a moan of satisfaction.

"I hope you don't mind," Debbie said while quickly getting in between Tami's legs to give her head, "but I need to have a taste."

Tami once again let out a moan of satisfaction, and kind of giggled when she said, "I can't really do anything about that, now can I?"

"No you can't," Debbie told her in a commanding voice. Then she added, "You should know that I love getting straight women off while they're tied and helpless to stop me. I'm not going to stop playing with you until I make you cum over, and over, and over again."

"Oh my God!" Exclaimed Tami as soon as Debbie turned a vibrator on, and pressed its head down onto Tami's already engorged clit. "What are you going to do to me?"

"I'm going to get you off," Debbie giggled, "and there's not a thing you can do to stop me!"

Continuing to give Tami head, at the same time Debbie inserted a couple of fingers into Tami's sopping wet pussy to find her G-spot, and then she massaged it, which suddenly made Tami's naked and bound body convulse with multiple orgasms.

"Shit, shit, shit!" Tami exclaimed while squirting her juices all over Debbie's face, and breasts, "Oh my God! You really know what you're doing!"

"Of course I do, sweetie," Debbie giggled. "I'm a woman. I know exactly how to make you cum, and get you to squirt!"

"I'm squirting?" Tami cried out as her orgasms intensified uncontrollably, and she begged Debbie to stop. "Oh my God! Please stop!"

Debbie eased up for a bit, but then she repeated what she had been doing until Tami started squirting uncontrollably again.

"Shit, shit, shit!" Tami exclaimed again while squirting uncontrollably. "Oh shit! Fuck me! Oh my God! What the hell are you doing to me? I'm like ... oh my God! I, uh, uh, I can't take any more!"

"Sure you can," Debbie chimed in to assure Tami that she could take more of what she was giving her. "Get it all out! Get it all out! And yes, I am going to fuck you, too!"

"What?" Tami cried out. "How are you going to fuck me?"

"With my strap-on," Debbie told her. "I'm going to fuck you with my strap-on, and there's nothing you can do to stop me!"

Not that she wanted Debbie to stop, both Robert and I could tell, but Tami protested anyway. But that only added to her excitement, which was clear to all of us, and clear to Tami as well.

"I can't believe I'm letting you do this," Tami laughed while Debbie fucked her with the strap-on that she brought with her.

"You're not letting me," Debbie reminded Tami with a knowing laugh. "I'm having my way with you. I'm taking what I want, and I'm going to keep fucking you until I get off on you."

Somewhat to my surprise, and to Robert's, although not entirely given how well things were going, Tami cried out, and said to Debbie, "Yes, yes, please take me. I want you to cum, too! I want you to get off on me!"

It was at that moment that Debbie let out a squeal of intense pleasure, and satisfaction. She exclaimed, "Oh yeah! Oh yeah! I'm cumming. Oh, shit! This is going to be a big one!"

After cumming hard, Debbie quickly pulled out, and deftly got into a sixty-nine position with Tami so that Tami could taste her, and so that Debbie could once again give Tami head.

With huge smiles on our faces, Robert and I looked at each other, and silently gave each other high fives because of what we were seeing. I could hardly believe how eagerly Tami was reciprocating Debbie's mouth, and tongue. It was a sight to see up close!

"I'm more than okay," Tami smiled. "That was really intense! All of it! What a rush!"

Debbie then laughed out loud, and said, "Oh shit! I forgot about the guys!"

Debbie looked over at us, and gave us a silent laugh.

"What guys?" Tami asked. "You mean Robert, right?"

Debbie stammered, and replied, "Well, I actually came over here with my boyfriend to help surprise you. But I think I just surprised myself by forgetting about him, and forgetting about Robert."

"Where are they?" Tami asked.

Not wanting to prolong the time it would take to show up had Robert and I gone someplace else, Debbie lied, and spontaneously answered, "They should be in the living room. That was the plan. They haven't stepped in once, which I told them they couldn't until I let them know that we were ready to have them join us," Debbie continued to lie. "Are you ready?"

"I guess so," Tami said in a disappointing tone of voice that amused me.

Skipping a beat as if we were in the living room we pretended to walk into the bedroom. We didn't say a word. We simply leaned down to suck Tami's toes. Robert grabbed onto her left foot, and I grabbed onto her right foot.

"Oh my!" Tami exclaimed. "There you two are! I like that!"

For quite a while, nothing else was said. Debbie, Robert, and I simply enjoyed each, and every inch of Tami's naked, and bound body. We made her cum a few more times, and then Robert and I took turns fucking her.

"Oh my God!" Tami exclaimed. "It's really hot to have two different guys fuck me. That's a first!"

A little later, Debbie announced to Tami, "Well, my man and I should be taking off. Thank you for letting us have our way with you."

"I should be thanking you, so thank you," Tami replied. "And shouldn't you be introducing your husband or boyfriend to me?"

Robert chimed in to say, "He's going to remain a mystery."

"Really?" Tami asked. "I don't get to know who he is?"

"Maybe some other time," Debbie chimed in to tell her. "We can come back if you'd like that."

"Most definitely!" Tami insisted. "I would definitely like to have both of you back."

"Thank you," Debbie replied. "We'll come back for sure."

"I can hardly wait," Tami told us.

"Neither can we," Debbie told her.

According to Robert, my ex Tami had no idea that I fucked her that night. She wasn't even given Debbie's name. Robert kept the two of us a mystery, which he said both frustrated, and delighted Tami. Even though Tami wanted to know who we are, she also liked not knowing our identities.

I suspected that she'd be fine knowing that I was the one who fucked her, and that Debbie's my partner. Even though Robert and Debbie thought that I was probably right about that, the three of us decided to keep Tami in the dark about our identities. As we repeated what happened that night the following week, and then in subsequent weeks after that, we decided to keep our identities a mystery.

In due time, from our circle of friends with benefits, we brought new play partners over to pleasure, and sexually ravish Tami in bondage while she was blindfolded, and our identities remained a mystery.