A Surprise Gone Wrong Goes Right

Published early on our Previews page on Thursday, August 22, 2024.

Official publication date for the main page of our site: Sunday, August 25, 2024.

This story was submitted anonymously.

Little did I know when I involved a lesbian friend of mine to help me surprise my boyfriend that the surprise would be on me. She was more than eager to help me because it meant that she'd get to see me restrained spread eagle completely naked. I didn't want to ask any of my straight girlfriends to help me because it would have been too awkward for me, and for them. But with my lesbian friend, I figured that she'd probably love to see me naked. I was right. She was very eager to help me.

Ahead of my boyfriend's expected arrival, my lesbian friend Jo came over to my apartment to get me ready for him. With the bondage gear that I recently purchased from an online sex toy store, she laid me on my back, and she restrained me spread eagle completely naked on my bed.

"Let me know if he's not enough for you, and I'll come back to make sure that you get off in a big way," she teased.

The plan was for Jo to answer the door for me when my boyfriend arrived, and then to leave after telling him about his surprise in the bedroom. What happened instead was a surprise gone wrong.

While we were waiting for my boyfriend to show up, he called my cell phone, and I had Jo put it on speakerphone for me so that I could talk to him. It was a short conversation. He told me that he was stuck at work, and that he wouldn't be able to see me until the next day after work. After he apologized, I told him not to worry about it, and that I'd see him the next day. That was the end of the call.

"Sorry to put you to all of this trouble for nothing," I told Jo.

"I was happy to do it," Jo replied. "Besides, it's not for nothing."

With a mischievous look on her face, she stretched her arms out after kneeling down at the foot of the bed, and she lightly traced her fingers along my soles.

"Ohhhh, that tickles," I told her while giggling.

"I wondered if your feet were ticklish," she replied. "I never told you this, but I have a foot fetish, and I've always wanted to worship your feet. You have the sexiest wrinkled soles that I've ever seen, and your toes are always so perfectly pedicured. They're really hard for me to resist."

When she started sucking my toes, I have to admit that I loved the sensation of having my toes sucked. It felt incredible, and she was really good at it.

"You seem to like having your toes sucked," she said with a smile. "Do you like it? Does it feel good?"

"It feels incredible!" I admitted.

"Good, because there's more to come," she cooed.

"Are you going to untie me?" I asked.

"Eventually, but I like having you tied up like this," she answered. "Do you like being tied?"

"This is my first time, so I don't know. I think I like it," I answered.

"I think you do, too, and I think you've wanted to be tied for a while now," she playfully replied. "Why else would you buy the restraints, and the gear that goes with it, right?"

"I guess so," I told her. "I did wonder what it would be like to be tied."

"Did you talk to your boyfriend about it?" She asked.

"No, not yet," I answered. "That's why I had you come over. You know, to have you get me ready for him, and to see if he'd like it. I wanted to surprise him."

"Well, now the surprise is on you," she laughed.

"I guess it is," I replied.

"Especially since you're tied and helpless to do anything about it," she reminded me.

"But you said you're going to untie me," I pouted.

"I said eventually," she reminded me with a laugh. "Right now I'm going to have some fun with you, and there isn't a thing that you can do about it."

I could have insisted that she untie me, and she would have because she's a really good friend, but the excitement I felt about it made me realize that I liked being tied, especially since it meant that Jo was going to take advantage of it, and have her way with me. I couldn't help but wonder what it was like for a woman with a foot fetish to do to me what I wished my boyfriend would do to my feet.

For the next few minutes I tried to see in my mind's eye my boyfriend sucking my toes, but I knew that he wouldn't be into it because he doesn't have a foot fetish. I knew that because whenever I asked him to give me a foot massage, he really only did it reluctantly, and he was never really good at it. He just kind of did it because I asked him to, and the foot massages never lasted very long. He never tickled my feet like I wanted them to be tickled, and he never sucked my toes either. I always wondered how that would feel.

Jo got right into it with me, which made it clear that she really does have a foot fetish. Not only was she sucking my toes, and quite expertly I might add, but she was also giving me one of the best foot massages that I had ever had. The very best!

At some point I blurted out what I was thinking.

"Wow! You're really good at this," I told her. "I've never had anybody give me so much pleasure through my feet before. Never!"

"I'm glad you like it," she replied. "I'm loving it!"

Jo was definitely into my feet because she kept kissing, licking, and tickling my soles, and she kept sucking my toes. I loved every moment of it. Every single moment!

When she started exploring the rest of my naked, and bound body with her fingers, mouth, and tongue, I was already so turned on, and aroused by what she'd be doing to my feet that I wanted her to worship, and have her way with the rest of my naked, and bound body. I couldn't help but want her to take full advantage of having me tied and helpless, and she knew it!

As I hoped she'd do, she also took full advantage of the sex toys that I laid out for my boyfriend's use on me, which I should point out she was so much better at using them than he ever was. He didn't really like to use them on me. I mean, he seemed kind of jealous of them. You know, like I wouldn't need him to get myself off, which of course I didn't need him to get me off.

Jo was different. She loved using sex toys to get me off, and she made me cum over, and over again. I was a wet mess the entire time that she sexually ravished me.

I never told my boyfriend about what happened with Jo that day. That surprise gone wrong ended up being a surprise gone right. Soon after, I stopped seeing him.

With Jo, I passively reciprocated the pleasure that she gave me by happily letting her use my naked and bound body as a human sex toy, which I love having her do, and which as she told me gave her great pleasure in return. I love the sensation of feeling her grind her pussy on my heels to get herself off, which usually results in her squirting her juices all over the soles of my feet. As for the toe sucking, I love that because she's always so good at it, and it always feels incredible!

As I cycle through different boyfriends with varying degrees of success, I continue to enjoy, and get off on my friends with benefits relationship with Jo. I sometimes joke with her that if I was a lesbian, I'd want us to be married.

She has a very relaxed attitude about the way that I am. She's fine with it. She jokes with me that maybe I'll end up getting married to a guy who likes to watch women have sex together, and that she'll simply be a 3rd wheel in my marriage.

I like the idea of that. Who knows? Maybe that's what will happen.